War of words heats up in GPO controversy

Auction Alert - Premier Medical Depot - Closing Dec 2nd - Bid on Over 365 Lots

La guerra de palabras calienta para arriba en controversia de GPO

por Brendon Nafziger, DOTmed News Associate Editor | October 07, 2010

The researchers based their estimates on potential cost-savings outside of GPOs by using data from from MEMdata, a service that works with hospitals trying to buy capital equipment. The researchers compared prices in so-called aftermarket auctions, in which GPO-contract vendors bid with contract prices against other vendors.

"We looked at price of medical supplies after GPOs have ostensibly secured best price," Singer said. "If original GPO auctions are done efficiently, [there's] no price room."

Servicing GE, Philips and Siemens CT equipment with OEM trained engineers

Numed, a well established company in business since 1975 provides a wide range of service options including time & material service, PM only contracts, full service contracts, labor only contracts & system relocation. Call 800 96 Numed for more info.


But in the report the researchers said that on average, through the 8,100 auctions studied, the winning bid was 10 to 14 percent cheaper than the original GPO price over the 10 years of data they had available. The average GPO price was $81,436, but the average winning bid was $73,990, according to the authors.

"Indeed, in [more than] half of all auctions in the transactions database, incumbent device makers on the GPO contract were induced to lower their own prices for the same product to the same hospital, and did so by approximately 7 percent on average," the report said.

GPOs call data 'discredited'
But the GPOs feel they have been vindicated by most non-industry studies. HIGPA said the data in the MDMA study have long been "discredited" by reams of earlier reports, including an Eight Circuit Court finding from August that upheld a verdict favoring C.R. Bard's contract with the GPO Novation. The court said it found hospitals pay, on average, 16 percent less for supplies through GPOs.

Plus, a much-touted report published by the GAO last week found that hospitals increasingly rely on GPOs as the primary means to help keep the costs of medical products and services balanced. In addition, the GAO found that most device vendors found voluntarily adopted rules by the GPOs helped keep administrative fees low and transparent. Three out of five vendors interviewed for the report said they are now paying lower administrative fees and that fees are more consistent and predictable, according to the report.

"Because medical device manufacturers did not like what the U.S. Government Accountability Office found in its most recent analysis of the group purchasing industry, MDMA has chosen to disregard or manipulate the GAO report for its own purposes," Rooney said.

But Bob Yancy, the CEO of MEMdata, from which the raw data from the MDMA study came, was quick to say the report should not be interpreted as an attack on GPOs. For decades, GPOs helped control supply prices and "drove price efficiency in our health care system," he noted.